by DaviddesJ
ira212 wrote:
I provide a reasoning for my ruling based on game balance, which is often a good reason for making game design decisions/rulings.
That may be true in general, but in this case your argument amounts to, "I personally think it's weak," which falls pretty short of actual reasoning.
In general, it can be hard to distinguish between "inclusive or" and "exclusive or" in English. It's one of the language's inherent ambiguities. But, in this case, it says, "either top or bottom," which is a pretty direct indication to choose one or the other, not both.